July 14, 4:20 PM 10

The Deep Bore Tunnel Isn’t a Done Deal

Today a group of individuals backing the deep bore tunnel held a press conference announcing that the tunnel is not a done deal.

As tunnel advocate Vlad Oustimovitch conceded, “In Seattle, nothing’s a done deal.”

For months tunnel supporters have tried to position the tunnel as a done deal as a way to quell public scrutiny despite the fact they have not released a finance plan and only 1% of the design work has been done.

McGinn said, “This is not a done deal. They clearly don’t want the public involved in this because the last time the public was involved 70% said no tunnel.”

Tunnel advocates today pointed out that the total project cost, before overruns, is $4.24 billion. The McGinn campaign has been using the number $4.2 billion. We regret the error.

subscribe to comments RSS

There are 10 comments for this post

  1. Tom Sparks says:

    Citizen votes on transportation issues seem to matter very little here, think Monorail.

    I am for a tunnel with an exit to downtown, let the people enjoy the waterfront. Routing traffic to city streets is an activist wet dream with no basis in reality.

  2. Elliott says:

    Thanks for the comment, Tom.

    As you probably know, this tunnel has no downtown exits, which was the only way the tunnel proponents could get their plan in front of the Governor. Even a single exit would dramatically increase the cost and would present an already experimental project with another massive engineering challenge.

    The I5/Surface/Transit plan that Mike favors was developed last year by a consensus of various citizen representatives and approved by WSDOT–hardly a bunch of activists… He’s actually in favor of substantial improvements to I5 throughput and surface street interface that have been in the works for some time now, but would cost significantly less than an experimental tunnel project under the heart of the city. Then we’d be able to meet transit demand, something we can’t even do today.

  3. Alex says:

    The $4.2 billion cost for the bored tunnel you cite includes costs that I understand we will incur regardless of whether a tunnel is built; for example, costs to rebuild the seawall. Why do you cite the $4.2 billion figure then when discussing the tunnel?

  4. John says:

    @alex,

    My answer to that would be, because you can’t do the one without the other. *Any* solution is going to require seawall rebuild - money the State won’t provide in any case. And the tunnel solution won’t work without significant transit improvements, which (a) as Elliott says we can’t meet currently, and (b) have to be included in the tunnel’s total cost. I’d say it’s more disingenuous to pretend the tunnel “only” costs $1.9 billion, or whatever the latest 2% engineered value is.

  5. bob says:

    Even less supported your option. Oh wait: that wasn’t even on the ballot, so claims of public support are pure fabrication.

  6. Enzyncnet says:

    hi
    Phentermine Pill
    Patients who are currently pregnant, plans on getting pregnant or currently breastfeeding are not advised to take this drug for it might harm you and your baby.
    Phentermine Prices
    It acts as an appetite suppressant to help reduce the weight of the patients when used short-term and combined with proper exercise, diet, and behaviour modification.
    http://www.thomas-street-tavern.com/ - Phentermine 37.5
    It was developed to help people suffering from obesity.

  7. David says:

    I was going to vote for McGinn because of his environmental record, but the whole tunnel issue is making me think twice.
    - Exits downtown would be nice, but not essential, especially if there are exits around Western and again south of Pioneer Square. The current viaduct only has one more than that in each direction.
    - dumping 99 traffic onto surface streets is fool hardy at best. I-5 is too jammed to take any more traffic. And, while I am a big supporter of light rail, biking, and other public transportation options, how does that help me with a truck full of electronics recycling? (Oh yeah, just like the Monorail twits “let’s make 15th one lane” who forgot that Holman-15th-99 is a very major trucking route in and out of Ballard, InterBay and connects north Seattle to the SoDo and industrial area - ever note the “Alt. Trucking RoOute” signs.)
    - The waterfront needs to be revamped and revitalized. It is no longer an industrial area suited to a viaduct. And, of coure, the current viaduct must go, whether we do it or the next earthquake does. It won’t take a 7.0 to drop it.
    - Finally, and most importantly, the Seawall MUST be replaced, and now. It should have been replaced 20 years ago. The patchwork repairs to date are like throwing Reese pieces into pudding to make it structurally sound.

    What are your solutions to the above, when will they be able to be implemented/completed, and how much will they cost?

    Thank you,
    David

  8. Cialis says:

    Erectile dysfunction, cialis, 8094, [URL=http://ajug.org/confluence/users/viewuserprofile.action?username=cialis]cialis[/URL], 8)8, http://ajug.org/confluence/users/viewuserprofile.action?username=cialis Cialis, bwzkq.

  9. David says:

    I didn’t vote for McGinn, and I’m passing on why: because in his criticism of the tunnel, which was fine on its merits, he never, in any comment I heard, said anything about what he would do for West Seattle. Oh, except that we all need to take more buses.

    Singling out one neighborhood and telling us to take public transportation, while other parts of the city are getting real PT choices (light rail), sent me packing from Mike. I was ready to vote for the guy the moment he came up with good options for us, but I never heard them. We tried for the monorail (in which case I was fine with taking out the viaduct), but downtown landowners nixed that. So we’re left with a part of Seattle that’s getting cut off from the rest.

    I hope Mike evaluates what’s best not only for the city as a whole, but for some of the specific neighborhoods. We have an impending sense of doom coming.

Please, feel free to post your own comment

* these are required fields